I'm not going to reread Brian's PF book (for the third or fourth time), but, to recapitulate, he has never denied Shade as the author of "Pale Fire" (the poem). When, in VN: TAY he set forth the "Shadean" thesis, he proposed that Shade had written all of Pale Fire (poem and novel). This is the position he abandoned, proposing that Shade was the author of the poem only. In his book on Pale Fire he does not propose that Hazel "wrote" the poem but that her ghost (real or imagined by JS and, perhaps, SS) was indeed a presence in Shade's final days, perhaps summoned up by his account of her life and death, and affected the poem that he wrote. Some of this ghostly presence may be manifest in jokes on the interfering Kinbote (the cat's collar, for example) and others like the appearance of the butterfly at the end (though Shade's writing about the butterfly precedes by at least some hours his actual death).
It's clear that Hazel Shade was, when alive, interested in making contact with the "other world," as the episode in the barn (recreated by CK from Shade's account) make clear. It also seems clear that the poltergeist events (again recreated by CK from Shade's account) were related to her; many reported (or reputed) poltergeist episodes center on young females, particularly those who are psychologically troubled.
"The Vane Sisters" is a VN story that contains a "message" from the other side. Whether or not VN actually believed in such matters is beside the point; if he'd had The Discovery Channel he could have watched all kinds of shows that present this evidence, but stuff of a similar nature was widely reported in popular magazines of the 50s and 60s. The Search for Bridey Murphy was, after all, a huge best-seller. Many of us are intrigued by such evidence but aren't totally convinced (nor do I suspect VN was–grist for an author's mill does not always yield the Bread of Life). The late James Merrill wrote an epic-length poem in which he claimed that much of it was dictated (in all-caps) by presences (among them W. H. Auden) who were summoned up via a Ouija Board wielded by JM and his partner, David Jackson. Yeats, to cite yet another example, was also fascinated by such matters.
The Arion Press edition, as I noted in an earlier post, was a limited (fewer than 300 copies) fine press edition that sold for $600, aimed at the collectors' market. The Gingko project is not like this at all.
From the outset, all involved in this project have proceeded from the idea that the poem (which Brian, I, and others consider a brilliant tour de force) is the work of Vladimir Nabokov, who has adopted the fictional persona of "John Shade" as its author. Publishing the poem by itself as a significant piece of 20th century poetry relieves us of the task of discussing it in the larger context of the novel. We both consider the poem a major artistic achievement and certainly VN's most significant poem in English. Though some continue to argue about whether the poem was written by John Shade, Charles Kinbote, or Hazel Shade, one thing remains clear: it was undoubtedly written by Vladimir Nabokov.
I trust that Brian will read this and correct anything I have said regarding his fine book on Pale Fire, even though any thesis about authorship being other than VN is irrelevant as far as the Gingko project is concerned.
Sam Gwynn
All private editorial communications, without
exception, are
read by both co-editors.