Jerry Frieman wrote to JM: I'm sorry if I was unclear.  There wasn't supposed to be any algebra in my most recent post.... I didn't realize till you mentioned it that "foreword" applies especially to something not written by the main author.  Kinbote's use of "preface" can probably be taken as evidence in favor of a single-author reading--if it hasn't been already. I made the unimaginative suggestion that it could be a mistake on Kinbote's or Nabokov's part.
The Vintage Edition of /Pale Fire/ starts with the dedication, then has the quotation from the /Life of Johnson/, then the "Contents".  I take it the table of contents is part of the fiction--either Kinbote or good old Frank is responsible....
JM to JF: In "Pale Fire's" Foreword we read: Frank has acknowledged the safe return of the galleys I had been sent here and has asked me to mention in my Preface and this I willingly do that I alone am responsible for any mistakes in my commentary. Insert before a professional. Therefore your suggestion, added to RSGwynn"s comments, set the ball rolling! If it were a mistake on Kinbote's part, what would have VN intended by it? A "lapsus" that revealed a single author?
Or could "Preface" have been employed, as it sometimes also occurs, only as a synonim of "Foreword"?
Does the entire sentence about prefaces mentioning Frank imply that what we see as a finished book was not actually the end-product of Frank's efforts & that we are reading something else, disguised as a published book? (it was posthumously printed, was it not? S and K were both dead, also G - the three main characters mentioned in the Index )
JF: Is it possible that /Lolita/ could be published without John  Ray, Jr.'s Foreword?  I'm appalled. 
JM: For me the Penguin edition with the cover: "Vladimir Nabokov The Annotated Lolita", and how its contents are listed is as mysterious as the absence of John Ray's foreword in the Collin's edition...

Search the Nabokv-L archive with Google

Contact the Editors

All private editorial communications, without exception, are read by both co-editors.

Visit Zembla

View Nabokv-L Policies